The Power of Tax Diversification: Why Having Different Tax Buckets Matters in Retirement
The Power of Tax Diversification: Why Having Different Tax Buckets Matters in Retirement
Introduction: Why Your Retirement Tax Strategy Is Just as Important as Your Investments
Most retirees spend their working years focused on growing their investments, but few consider the tax impact of how they withdraw their money in retirement.
If all your money is in tax-deferred accounts, you could be hit with a massive tax bill when Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) kick in at age 73. On the other hand, having too much in tax-free accounts may mean missing out on valuable tax deductions.
The key to a smart retirement withdrawal strategy? Tax diversification.
By spreading your savings across different tax buckets, you gain more control over:
✅ Your taxable income in retirement (keeping you in lower tax brackets).
✅ How much of your Social Security benefits are taxed.
✅ Your Medicare premiums (avoiding IRMAA surcharges).
✅ The legacy you leave to your heirs (minimizing their tax burden).
Let’s break down why tax diversification is a must-have for high-net-worth retirees.
The Three Tax Buckets Every Retiree Should Have
Not all retirement accounts are taxed the same way. To create a tax-efficient withdrawal strategy, it’s best to spread your assets across these three tax buckets:
1. Taxable Bucket (Brokerage Accounts, CDs, Savings Accounts)
💡 How It’s Taxed:
- Investments in this bucket are subject to capital gains tax (not ordinary income tax).
- Long-term capital gains tax rates (0%, 15%, or 20%) are often lower than income tax rates.
- Interest and dividends may be taxed annually.
✔ Best Uses:
✅ Provides liquidity for short-term needs without increasing your taxable income dramatically.
✅ Allows you to take advantage of low capital gains tax rates.
✅ Good for funding early retirement years before Social Security or RMDs start.
🚀 Example Strategy:
- Withdraw money from taxable accounts first in early retirement to delay tapping tax-deferred accounts and reduce RMDs later.
2. Tax-Deferred Bucket (401(k), Traditional IRA, 403(b), SEP IRA, Annuities)
💡 How It’s Taxed:
- Contributions were tax-deductible when made (lowering your taxable income while working).
- Withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income.
- Subject to RMDs starting at age 73.
✔ Best Uses:
✅ Allows for tax-deferred growth, which is great for long-term investing.
✅ Useful before age 73, when you can strategically withdraw at lower tax rates.
✅ Good for charitable giving strategies (via QCDs).
🚀 Example Strategy:
- Before RMDs kick in, withdraw from tax-deferred accounts strategically to fill lower tax brackets.
- Consider Roth conversions before 73 to reduce future RMDs.
3. Tax-Free Bucket (Roth IRA, Roth 401(k), HSA)
💡 How It’s Taxed:
- No taxes on withdrawals (if held for at least 5 years and over age 59½).
- No RMDs on Roth IRAs (Roth 401(k)s do have RMDs, but they can be rolled into a Roth IRA to avoid them).
- Grows tax-free for life and heirs receive tax-free distributions.
✔ Best Uses:
✅ Acts as a buffer against tax increases in retirement.
✅ Perfect for legacy planning (since heirs don’t owe income tax on Roth IRAs).
✅ Can be used in years when higher taxable income would trigger Medicare IRMAA surcharges.
🚀 Example Strategy:
- Withdraw from Roth IRAs in high-tax years to avoid moving into a higher bracket.
- Convert tax-deferred assets into a Roth IRA before RMDs begin to build up tax-free income.
How to Use Tax Diversification to Reduce Taxes in Retirement
A tax-diversified portfolio allows you to customize your withdrawals based on your tax situation each year.
Here’s how a retiree can use all three tax buckets to create a flexible and tax-efficient withdrawal strategy:
Step 1: Withdraw from the Taxable Bucket First (Early Retirement, Ages 60-73)
✔ Take money from brokerage accounts (capital gains taxed at a lower rate than ordinary income).
✔ This allows you to delay Social Security (for a higher payout later) and reduce future RMDs.
Step 2: Use Tax-Deferred Accounts Strategically (Mid-Retirement, Ages 65-73)
✔ Start small withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts to prevent large RMDs later.
✔ If you have low taxable income, consider Roth conversions to move money into the tax-free bucket.
Step 3: Mix and Match Buckets Based on Tax Brackets (After RMDs Start at Age 73+)
✔ Take only the required RMDs from tax-deferred accounts.
✔ Use Roth IRA withdrawals in years when additional income would push you into a higher tax bracket.
✔ Avoid Medicare IRMAA surcharges by keeping taxable income below key thresholds.
Why Tax Diversification Helps You Keep More of Your Money
🚀 Without Tax Diversification:
- You might be forced into high tax brackets due to RMDs.
- You could trigger Medicare IRMAA surcharges by taking large withdrawals in one year.
- You may lose tax-efficient opportunities by withdrawing only from tax-deferred accounts.
✅ With Tax Diversification:
- You can strategically withdraw from different buckets to stay in lower tax brackets.
- You have flexibility to adjust withdrawals based on tax law changes.
- You can leave a tax-free legacy for heirs by using Roth accounts.
Final Thoughts: Take Control of Your Retirement Tax Strategy
Having a diversified investment portfolio is great—but having a diversified tax strategy is just as important.
By spreading your assets across taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-free accounts, you gain:
✅ More control over your tax bill.
✅ Lower lifetime taxes and reduced RMD burdens.
✅ The ability to leave more wealth to your heirs—tax-free.
📥 Download Your Free Retirement Readiness Checklist Here Download Here
📅 Schedule a Consultation to Build a Tax-Efficient Retirement Plan Click Here
Securities offered through Van Clemens & Co., member FINRA/SIPC. Advisory services offered through Van Clemens Wealth Management, a registered investment advisor. Van Clemens & Co. and Van Clemens Wealth Management are separate entities from Inspire Financial Services. CA License: 4234803.