The Bucket Strategy vs. Guardrails: Which Retirement Income Plan Works Best?
The Bucket Strategy vs. Guardrails: Which Retirement Income Plan Works Best?
Introduction: The Retirement Income Puzzle
One of the biggest challenges retirees face is turning their savings into a reliable stream of income that lasts a lifetime. The fear of outliving your money is real, and retirees often ask:
- How should I structure my retirement withdrawals?
- Should I take money from my investments monthly or only when needed?
- How do I make sure I don’t run out of money?
Two of the most popular strategies for managing retirement withdrawals are the Bucket Strategy and the Guardrails Distribution Strategy. Each approach has its pros and cons, and the right choice depends on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and goals.
Let’s compare these two methods so you can determine which one might be the best fit for your retirement.
What Is the Bucket Strategy?
The Bucket Strategy divides your retirement savings into different “buckets” based on time horizons and risk levels. The idea is to keep enough cash and conservative investments for short-term needs while allowing long-term investments to grow.
How It Works:
1️⃣ Short-Term Bucket (0-3 Years)
- Holds cash, money market funds, CDs, or short-term bonds.
- Provides immediate income to cover expenses.
- Protects against market downturns by avoiding forced withdrawals from investments.
2️⃣ Medium-Term Bucket (3-10 Years)
- Includes a mix of bonds and dividend-paying stocks.
- Balances growth with stability.
- Replenishes the short-term bucket when needed.
3️⃣ Long-Term Bucket (10+ Years)
- Invested in stocks, real estate, or other growth-oriented assets.
- Designed to outpace inflation and support spending later in retirement.
- Funds are gradually moved into the medium-term bucket as needed.
✔ Pros of the Bucket Strategy:
✅ Helps reduce sequence of returns risk by ensuring you have cash available during market downturns.
✅ Provides psychological comfort by keeping short-term income separate from long-term investments.
✅ Allows for market growth in the long-term bucket.
❌ Cons of the Bucket Strategy:
🚫 Can be overly conservative, limiting long-term portfolio growth.
🚫 Requires regular monitoring and rebalancing between buckets.
🚫 Cash sitting in the short-term bucket may lose value due to inflation.
What Is the Guardrails Distribution Strategy?
The Guardrails Strategy takes a more dynamic approach to retirement withdrawals, adjusting spending based on market conditions. Instead of keeping separate “buckets,” this method maintains a total portfolio with spending guardrails to prevent overspending or unnecessary frugality.
How It Works:
1️⃣ Set an Initial Withdrawal Rate (e.g., 4-5% of portfolio).
2️⃣ Establish Guardrails – Spending adjustments happen if the portfolio rises or falls by a set percentage (e.g., 10-20%).
3️⃣ Make Small Adjustments When Needed – If the portfolio performs well, spending can increase. If it drops below the lower guardrail, spending is temporarily reduced.
✔ Pros of the Guardrails Strategy:
✅ More flexibility—allows for higher spending in strong market years while protecting assets in downturns.
✅ Helps avoid running out of money by adjusting withdrawals based on portfolio performance.
✅ Less cash drag—your assets remain invested for potential growth rather than sitting idle in cash.
❌ Cons of the Guardrails Strategy:
🚫 Requires some discipline to adjust spending when necessary.
🚫 Can be emotionally difficult to lower withdrawals during downturns.
🚫 Works best when regularly monitored with a financial advisor.
Which Strategy Is Right for You?
Both strategies aim to ensure a sustainable income in retirement, but they cater to different mindsets and risk tolerances.
Feature
Bucket Strategy
Guardrails Strategy
Simplicity
Moderate (requires rebalancing)
More complex (requires monitoring and spending adjustments)
Flexibility
Lower (fixed buckets)
Higher (adjusts with market conditions)
Risk Protection
Short-term protection via cash reserves
Long-term protection via adaptive withdrawals
Market Growth Potential
Limited (cash drag in short-term bucket)
Higher (more assets stay invested)
Emotional Comfort
Higher (separate buckets for peace of mind)
Moderate (requires spending flexibility)
✔ Choose the Bucket Strategy if:
- You prefer a structured, conservative approach.
- You want peace of mind knowing you have several years of cash reserves.
- You don’t mind rebalancing between buckets periodically.
✔ Choose the Guardrails Strategy if:
- You want to maximize market growth while maintaining spending flexibility.
- You’re comfortable making spending adjustments based on market performance.
- You prefer a more dynamic withdrawal strategy that adapts over time.
Blending Both Strategies: A Hybrid Approach
For many retirees, combining elements of both strategies can provide the best of both worlds.
💡 Example of a Hybrid Approach:
- Keep 1-2 years of cash reserves (Bucket Strategy) to cover immediate expenses.
- Use the Guardrails Strategy to guide withdrawals from your investment portfolio.
- Maintain flexibility by adjusting withdrawals if the market performs poorly.
This hybrid method ensures you have short-term security and long-term growth, allowing for a more stress-free retirement.
Final Thoughts: A Sustainable Retirement Income Plan
The right strategy for your retirement depends on your risk tolerance, spending habits, and long-term financial goals. Whether you prefer the structured Bucket Strategy or the flexible Guardrails Strategy, having a solid withdrawal plan ensures you enjoy your wealth without fear of running out of money.
If you’re unsure which strategy best fits your retirement lifestyle, we can help.
📥 Download Your Free Retirement Readiness Checklist Here Download Here
📅 Schedule a Consultation to Build Your Retirement Income Plan Click Here
Securities offered through Van Clemens & Co., member FINRA/SIPC. Advisory services offered through Van Clemens Wealth Management, a registered investment advisor. Van Clemens & Co. and Van Clemens Wealth Management are separate entities from Inspire Financial Services. CA License: 4234803.